In recent years, a prominent strategy among industry leaders has been the formation of collaborative agreements to defy market trends and achieve mutual success. Companies within the sector are increasingly engaging in joint ventures, aiming to broaden their target consumer bases and extend their reach across different jurisdictional markets.
Collaborative Agreements
Structuring the collaborative agreements requires careful attention. For instance, provisions regarding the severability of an agreement must be meticulously crafted, and the ability to enforce rights in case of third-party conflicts or infringements must be judiciously included. Issues of transfer pricing and the delicate balance of royalties paid by one company versus the resources used by the other must also be addressed comprehensively.
Trademark definitions, including usage by exports, necessitate that joint ventures consider the scope of territorial rights and expansions. Additionally, non-compete provisions and compliance with competition law principles must be integrated into the agreements. India boasts successful models of joint ventures such as Toyota Kirloskar, Maruti Suzuki, and the historic Hero Honda collaboration.
Flexibility clauses are essential in these agreements to allow for negotiations and dispute avoidance. For example, the 2016 partnership between Toyota Motor and Suzuki Motor was a significant milestone. This joint venture, aimed at market expansion through “cross-branding” or “co-branding,” saw both companies leveraging their strengths. Toyota’s robust technological prowess in electrification and Suzuki’s expertise in compact vehicular mechanisation were combined to introduce a new sports utility vehicle under both brand names, Maruti Suzuki India and Toyota Kirloskar Motor.
As part of this partnership, Suzuki’s popular models such as the Sedan Baleno, Ciaz, and Vitara were rebranded under the Toyota name, while Toyota’s Corolla was redesigned and launched under the Suzuki brand. With approximately 43% of Toyota’s India sales attributed to Maruti Suzuki cars, this partnership has proven to be a mutually beneficial alliance, demonstrating the strategic advantages of collaboration in the dynamic automotive industry. This collaboration also involved a shareholding exchange, with Toyota acquiring a 4.94% stake in Suzuki through a USD908 million investment and Suzuki acquiring a 0.22% stake in Toyota with a USD454 million investment.
Intellectual Property Challenges
Despite the success of collaborative models, intellectual property disputes remain a significant challenge. The India Brand Equity Foundation highlights that the Indian auto component industry is poised to become the third-largest globally by 2025, with auto component exports expected to reach USD30 billion by FY26. However, the rapid industrial growth is accompanied by the issue of counterfeit parts and components, which lack safety checks and pose threats to consumer safety and intellectual property rights.
To address this, automotive companies must proactively take measures against counterfeiters and make authorised spare parts more accessible. Standardised regulations at custom houses and vigilant monitoring of import and export flows are also crucial. A notable case is Monte Carlo Fashions resolving its trademark dispute with Skoda Auto India, where Monte Carlo licensed the trademark “MONTE CARLO” to Skoda India for limited use.
Design Issues
Design infringement is another concern. An international case in 2023 saw the US District Court for the Eastern District of Michigan ruling in favour of Mahindra & Mahindra in a design infringement case brought by Fiat Chrysler Automobiles. The dispute involved the “grille design” of Fiat’s Jeep and Mahindra’s Roxor off-roader, which was deemed distinguishable despite similarities. This ruling highlights the importance of recognising contributory intellectual property when prototypes are adapted for specific markets.
The Impact of AI
The rise of artificial intelligence (AI) in the automotive industry brings additional legal implications. Issues surrounding AI-generated works and data privacy are increasingly relevant. While the US and UK have refused to grant patents to AI systems like DABUS, South Africa and Australia have recognised AI as a patent inventor. The ethical concerns of data management in autonomous vehicles also pose significant challenges, particularly regarding hacking and personal data breaches.
Patents and Trade Secrets
As the automotive sector evolves, the focus of patents is shifting from mechanical engineering to computer technology. The deployment of communication technologies such as GPS, 3G, 4G, LTE, and 5G involves negotiating licences on FRAND terms with major communication companies. The Daimler and Nokia dispute over SEP licensing exemplifies this challenge.
The trend in patent filings now includes AI-integrated vehicles and vehicle control systems, with innovations like self-parking cars and gesture control systems. Trade secrets offer an alternative form of protection, but maintaining secrecy and proving misappropriation remain challenges due to the large volume of proprietary information and the collaborative nature of the industry.
Conclusion
The rapid growth of the global automobile sector brings with it a host of legal concerns. Companies, regardless of their size, must adopt enterprising and cautious business strategies, keeping a keen eye on the dynamic changes and legal ramifications within the sector. By navigating these complexities with foresight and diligence, the industry can continue to thrive amidst evolving challenges.
Link : https://www.linkedin.com/company/kumar-sardana-associates-ksa
